I have occasionally participated in conversations on the topic of “good people.” Why are so many Christians bad people in the world? Why are so many non-Christians good, loving and helpful?
Here is my final answer: I don’t know.
This is certainly not a new phenomenon. The Bible is full of stories about the giants of faith who made miserable mistakes—David arranging the killing of Uriah, Abraham lying about his wife in order to save his life, the disciples wanting to call down fire on the Samaritan village.
And we also find the opposite in the Bible. When the Centurian came to Jesus with his request, Jesus said he hadn’t seen such great faith in all of
Maybe this question stems from false expectations. There are good and bad Christians. There are good and bad non-Christians. We expect all of one to be perfect and all of the other to be devils, but that’s just not how the Bible describes reality.
Jesus told the parable of the wheat and tares—good and bad people (Matt. 13:24-30). The context is either the world or the church, and I've been told it's the church. He said to let the wheat and tares grow together, and in the end he would set it right. He’ll weed out the wolves in sheep clothing (excuse the mixed metaphor) when he comes back.
Conversely, in Revelation 14 we learn that God recognizes the existence of his kids outside of his formal church. He says, “Come out of
I don’t really know why, but in reality there are good non-Christians and some pretty evil people who carry the name of Christian. God knows who belongs to him.
Two portions of the Bible that relate to this topic have interested me. The first is in Matthew 7:21-23 when Jesus teaches that some people who do miracles in his name will be rejected at the 2nd coming. Clearly, discerning who is truly following Jesus is not so clear.
The second is at the end of the same book, Matthew 25:31-46. Here Jesus reveals his true followers. They are the ones who have fed the hungry, clothed the poor, helped the sick, given shelter to the homeless, and visited prisoners in jail. Even though they don’t know Jesus, they are welcomed home for their kindness to him.
2 comments:
hey jeff, i read this and your other post about christians & what constitutes christianity and i think you answered your own question:
"Here Jesus reveals his true followers. They are the ones who have fed the hungry, clothed the poor, helped the sick, given shelter to the homeless, and visited prisoners in jail. Even though they don’t know Jesus, they are welcomed home for their kindness to him."
i do not believe that if you are a cruel or heartless person you are a bad-christian... you simply are not a christian. and just because you don't claim to be a christian, but are in all ways kind and decent and compassionate, doesn't mean you're a non-christian. "christian" is an extremely loaded word...but ultimately it should come down to living as christ lived--caring for the poor, the children, the "sinners" (a whole other discussion), etc...
we see a lot of bad people who call themselves christian (especially in politics and the evangelical movement). and there are a lot of good people who would never dare to call themselves christian. i think the label isn't the important issue, it's the way we live our lives.
(dana w.)
hey jeff, so i've been thinking more about my post and i know that i overgeneralized (good people=true christian; bad people=non-christian). i know there's more to it than that.
but i do believe that people that are truly good and decent and kind are listening to that "still, small voice" and are searching for Truth.
this issue gets stickier, but i deeply believe that the search for Truth is the issue here. we're all going to be "bad" sometimes, but if we are constantly searching, then that is how we see god.
i used to go on a "spiritual" forum and i loved discussing spirituality and Truth with the hindu believers. they have this idea that Truth/god/enlightenment is like a big elephant and we're all blind, touching one part of the elephant. you might have the trunk and understand the elephant (Truth/god) one way, and i've got a foot and understand it a different way...but as long as we've got our hands on the elephant, and communicate this to each other, we're gaining a bigger and better understanding of it.
i may have veered off...as i often do (i am not a linear thinker), but the quest for Truth will take us further than just wanting to be a certain religion.
thanks for reading my ramblings :)
peace,
dana w.
Post a Comment